Pizza Plus

Discover Pizza Plus in Cadillac, MI—your family-owned pizza spot serving delicious homemade crust, thin crust pizza, subs, pizza pockets, and flavorful garlic cheese bread. Call +1 231-775-7727 today!

Welcome to Pizza Plus

Taste the Difference.

Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus

Pizza Plus stands as a beloved establishment in Cadillac, Michigan. Located at 302 N Mitchell St, it captures the essence of a mom and pop pizza place that’s become a staple for locals. The restaurant brings warmth and familiarity, offering a menu filled with homemade dishes that speak to the heart of comfort food. Diners rave about the original subs and garlic cheese bread, both of which leave lasting impressions. With a family-owned charm, it attracts both regulars and newcomers seeking a taste of authentic thin-crust pizza. Whether diners choose to savor a hearty meal with loved ones or grab a quick bite, Pizza Plus delivers a satisfying experience. Frequented often, the bustling atmosphere especially comes alive on Friday evenings.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

302 N Mitchell St, Cadillac, MI 49601, United States

Phone

+1 231-775-7727

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus

Pizza Plus isn't just about great food; it's about community. This family-owned business takes pride in its roots, making it a true cornerstone of Cadillac. Since opening its doors, it has become a gathering spot for friends and families, fostering connections over delicious meals. The owners prioritize quality, ensuring every dish is made with care. Each pizza features a homemade crust, and subs are crafted to perfection, creating an irresistible pull for both regulars and first-time visitors. Specialty pizzas like the OHS and Super showcase creativity and flavor, drawing on classic recipes while adding unique twists that appeal to adventurous eaters.

The extensive menu includes favorites like the garlic cheese bread and wet burrito, providing plenty of options for those who appreciate variety in their meals. The commitment to freshness translates into a unique dining experience that captures the essence of Cadillac's culinary scene. Whether visiting for lunch or dinner, diners find a warm atmosphere that invites them to linger a little longer. In a real sense, Pizza Plus embodies local values, community involvement, and a steadfast dedication to quality food that keeps everyone coming back.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Pizza Plus delivers a broad and delicious menu featuring 31 unique dishes that cater to diverse tastes. Among the highlights are specialty pizzas like BLT and CBR, which tantalize taste buds, and a variety of subs that range from meatball to vegetarian options. Visitors should also not miss the popular pizza pockets that make for a quick and satisfying meal.

The restaurant's commitment to homemade cuisine is evident, particularly in its freshly made crusts that elevate every pizza. The venue provides a casual dining experience, accommodating both small families and larger groups. During peak times, the restaurant buzzes with energy, crafting a vibrant dining atmosphere that remains welcoming.

Pizza Plus

The exterior of Pizza Plus invites guests with a distinctly quaint charm. The building's design exudes a classic pizza dive vibe, reflecting its welcoming atmosphere. Bright signage hints at the delicious offerings inside. Arriving at this cozy spot, patrons quickly sense the community spirit. The outdoor seating option adds a casual touch, making it perfect for enjoying a meal in pleasant weather. The vibe inside is lively and energetic, especially during peak hours when laughter and chatter fill the air, creating a feel-good ambiance that encourages diners to enjoy their meals.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

OMG! Pizza Plus has THE best subs! We got the original subs tonight and they are AMAZING! Third bite in and I am on my second napkin! That is the sign of something amazing!! The service is amazing, too! They are always so friendly and happy to help! Thank you for the best Saturday night dinner!

R
Rebecca G.

My absolute FAVORITE pizza in Cadillac. And I've tried them ALL. Thin crust. Quality NY style pie with AMAZING Italian sausage. Sauce was PERFECT (not sweet).

T
Tammy M.

This place is great and you can smell the aroma of fresh pizzas and dough being made. The pizza was amazing but this interior needs some attention. There are holes in the walls and ceiling, the dust clings to the top of the restaurant just out of reach of the aging fans that circulate air through the small enclosed space. It's a great restaurant that is tied to the area and honestly it just needs some love.

T
T T.

When we are in a new place, it's tradition to have local pizza for our first evenings dinner. Here, we made the perfect choice! In fact, the during our first week, we had Pizza Plus for 3 meals. Pizza and their enormous plating of spaghetti. Pizza Plus is centered around tradition, excellent food, kind and helpful staff and deep rooted nostalgia of downtown Cadillac. If you are ever in the area, craving great pizza and superb tasting food, Pizza Plus is without a doubt a fantastic choice! Their menu is very affordable, in my opinion, leaning more towards inexpensive.

G
Good F.

Talk about a hidden gem! Granted, the place isn't hidden but it's not talked about as much as it deserves! This family is on its third generation owning the business, the pizza and bread sticks were PHENOMENAL and the price was great! We will be returning to try the subs next! YUM YUM FULL TUMMY!!

S
Sammantha B.

Did not expect much from this small place but everything we ordered was excellent! Delicious pizza, salad, and wet burrito! The folks running this place are super friendly, and the prices are great.

A
Alexander B.